I tried building my site with the 3 top AI bots; I found an undisputed winner

Every time I tested multiple AI providers to build the same tool, I found one of them to be more intelligent than the others. However, the prompts were not exactly the same, so I couldn’t compare the results.

This time I gave Gemini, ChatGPT, and Claude the exact same prompt. I asked for a used car dealership website that includes a homepage, an inventory page, and a page for viewing a single vehicle’s details.

What Happened

I wanted to test the reasoning capability of the AI models, so I kept the prompt somewhat vague on purpose. All three models understood the basic structure and returned a working website.

• An entry named “2020 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Rubicon” has an image of an empty road.

• There is an entry for a “2019 Ford F-150 Lariat 4x4” with an image of a Ferrari supercar.

• However, I still didn’t explicitly mention something like “realistic used-car photos.” It just figured out the intent on its own.

Key Details

All three also included the usual dealership messages, such as how the vehicles were tested and how the pricing is transparent. Every AI model successfully executed the basic instructions.

• For the sake of a fair comparison, I asked Claude to use real images.

• If I had chosen a different type of project, perhaps something focused squarely on the core logic or the website design, the result might have been more competitive with the rest.

• But the purpose of this project was to compare the capabilities of different AI models.

Why It Matters

I used the most capable models and settings available to free users: Gemini 3.6 Flash with Extended Thinking enabled, ChatGPT with its only available Think mode checked, and Claude Sonnet 5 with Thinking enabled and the effort set to Extra. Claude technically.

• The AI says pulling real images from the internet with brand logos would invite copyright concerns.

• Claude initially took a different approach to the images.

What Reports Say

Coverage of the story so far points to:

• Continued reporting by Android Police as more details emerge